Smartphone apps are not typically developed with young people’s needs in mind. Social media, in particular, can expose teenagers to inappropriate or harmful content, but it can also provide a community and a space to learn. What would it look like if we took a safety-first approach to smartphones and young people? That’s what Candice Odgers, an expert on adolescent mental health, is calling for.

At a Jacobs Foundation event at the University of Zurich, Odgers argued that while teens are being told that social media is destroying their brains and that they’re addicted to their phones, that’s not what the evidence shows. Yet this is partly the premise under which under-16s are banned from social media in Australia, and perhaps will be soon in other countries as well. According to an early report, around 80% of young people in Australia are still using social media. Odgers points out that policy discussions around protecting children online should take into account the uncertainty of the evidence and opt for a safety-first approach. This would be consistent with the science and less harmful.

“Policy discussions around protecting children online should take into account the uncertainty of the evidence.”

What should tech companies do?

Social media platforms can and should do more to protect young people – and all users of their tools. Odgers would like to see more content moderation, ensuring that damaging content, such as a deepfake of a young person, is removed within seconds of posting. She would also like users to be given more control over their feeds so that they can choose what they want to consume. Ultimately, Odgers wants to see improvements in platforms and the internet overall, to benefit all of us. Nobody should have to see toxic content.

More on phones
Should young people be banned from using smartphones?

What can caregivers and educators do?

Many young people already know more than adults about how to curate their feeds, spot misinformation, and recognise AI-generated content, Odgers says. So, one of the first things adults can do is talk to the young people in their lives to learn from them and find out what they already know and what they are already doing.

But smartphones and social media are far from the most important factors affecting mental health. Young people say that the biggest pressures affecting their mental health are stress at home and academic pressure at school. And in a recent study, Odgers found that daily fluctuations in phone use did not predict how adolescents felt the next morning. Interestingly, those who felt more negative in the morning spent more time using their phone passively over the course of that day. Odgers sees a large gap between what many people believe and what the science says about the effects of digital technology.

“Bans on phones or social media won’t fix mental health, but supporting young people as they navigate the stresses of home and school can make a difference.”

If we really want to protect young people’s mental health, we should also look elsewhere. At school, do children feel like they belong? And outside of school, do children eat enough nutritious food and get enough quality sleep? Are they living in families under financial strain? Are they free from discrimination and violence? Each of these things impacts young people’s wellbeing. What’s more, restricting access to online spaces takes away opportunities to connect, build community, and prepare to navigate online spaces as adults.

The digital world should be made safer for young people, and Odgers would like to see platforms held to account. If we focus only on digital technology, however, we overlook all the other factors the evidence is clear on. Bans on phones or social media won’t fix mental health, but supporting young people as they navigate the stresses of home and school can make a difference.

Footnotes

The Jacobs Foundation hosted a keynote from Candice Odgers at the University of Zurich on Tuesday 3 November 2026. Candice was joined by Moritz Daum, Christa Schmid-Meier, and Daniel Süss in a session moderated by Gelgia Fetz Fernandes. You can watch the whole event here.